Jonathan O. Corder, CSA, a Man of Many Battalions

Let's skip ahead more than 100 years and talk for a minute about Edward Corder Sr.'s great-great-grandson, Jonathan O. Corder of Scott County, VA, and his service during the American Civil War. Why? Because I am a non-linear researcher.

I have tried to untangle Jonathan's web of transfers and battalion splits which, when combined with the lack of accurate rosters from some of his units, were complex enough to cause even the pension office to challenge his claims of service. Add to this the fact that the Virginia Regimental Series mis-transcribed Jonathan's name as "Corden" (an easy mistake in days when spidery script made an "r" looked like an "n", and one that possibly appeared on the original documents), and all of that makes Jonathan a hard feller to foller. But here's what I've been able to make out...

Military Service - CSA
On the 21st of March 1862, at about the age of twenty, Jonathan O. Corder enlisted in the 1st. Battalion Kentucky Mounted Rifles in Dungannon, Virginia, near his home in Osborne's Ford (Scott County). His original pension application dates the beginning of his service as May1862 and adds that he enlisted in General Marshall [illegible] Regiment, Company E. His immediate superior officers were “Major Bradley” and “Captain Bob Stoner.” He mentions fellow comrades in arms Nathan Dickenson and cousin Stephen J. Osborne, who, when his pension application was challenged in 1916, later swore oaths that Jonathan did indeed serve with them during the course of the war. The challenge arose due to the lack of complete rosters for some of the units in which Jonathan served.

Jonathan was transferred November 20, 1862 from the Kentucky Mounted Rifles to Vinson A. Witcher's 34th Battalion Virginia Cavalry. The 34th cavalry performed more in the capacity of mounted infantry, riding in, dismounting and firing at an advancing line. The Virginia Regimental Series notes that:

“Early in the war, Witcher and the 1st Battalion Virginia Mounted Rifles (precursor to the 34th) developed a dual reputation. One Confederate officer commented that Witcher could not pass up a farm that had a fine horse in the field. Most disparaging remarks, however were initiated by the bitter John B. Floyd, a political general and past governor of Virginia. Merited or not, Floyd's use of polemics helped to establish a tainted reputation for the unit, that was perpetuated by Yankee officers. Witcher and the 34th Battalion were greatly appreciated by other Confederate officers though. The immortal J.E.B. Stuart and Robert E. Lee, each highly praised the unit, and Stuart wrote an enviable commendation for Witcher.”

The company of Captain Caldwell (including Jonathan) was withdrawn from Witcher’s battalion and divided between Captain Caldwell and Captain McFarlane. Jonathan was assigned to Captain McFarlane's Company of Virginia Cavalry, which was then split into Jesse's Battalion of Kentucky Mounted Riflemen, and the 6th Battalion Confederate Cavalry.

Some sources say that Jesse's Battalion of Kentucky Mounted Riflemen became the 6th Battalion Cavalry of the Confederate States. (Jonathan's gravestone bears an inscription attesting to his service in Company E of this battalion.) In May of 1864 Jesse's Mounted Riflemen and the 6th Confederate Cavalry became companies H, and I of Witcher's 34th Virginia Cavalry. Jonathan Corder's Company H, was commanded by Capt. Robert C. Boyd, formerly a second lieutenant in McFarlane's Company.

When asked on his pension application when and why he left the service, Jonathan replied “at the surrender, at home in Scott County, VA [illegible]” but when questioned later he responded that he was “unable to tell where I was in April ‘64.” He adds that he was in the Cavalry during his whole time in service, having joined under Major Bradley of Kentucky, with whom he served for twelve months before being transferred to a Virginia Battalion under Captain McFarlane. He then recounts that the battalion was divided, and he ended up under Captain Boyd. He ends “later, and for the rest of the War, I was under Col. Witcher. I do not now remember the number of this Battalion, but it was a Virginia Company.”

If you'd like to take a look at Jonathan's pension application and his subsequent correspondence with the pension office, you can download a PDF here from the Edward Corder Memorial Library. If you can make out the words better than I have, please correct my information in comments below.

Edward Corder I > Edward Corder II > Elijah Corder I > Elijah Corder II > Jonathan O. Corder